Hertz Car Rental Review Problems
Hertz is a workable rental choice, but the biggest problems usually show up at reservation changes, counter wait times, car substitutions, and post-return charges, so check each step before you pay. Miss one detail and you can lose time, miss your departure, or spend weeks disputing a bill. This guide breaks down the failure points in booking, pickup, return, and billing, plus the checks that cut your risk.
Hertz problems checklist table
| Stage | Most common failure mode | Red flag to watch for | Action before leaving the lot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Booking | Reservation changes, booking-class swaps, or unclear fee terms | Terms mention amendment limits, extra charges, or a class that does not match the car you expect | Capture the rate, class, pickup time, and cancellation terms on screen before you confirm |
| Pickup | Counter congestion, slow service, or a different car class than booked | Long line, no clear estimate for wait time, or staff steering you to “similar” vehicles | Inspect the exact class, fuel level, mileage, and any damage before you leave the curb or garage |
| Vehicle condition | Mechanical issues, warning lights, dirty interior, or unrecorded damage | Dash lights, tire wear, low fluid warnings, or scratches that are not on the rental sheet | Photograph every panel, wheel, glass area, and the dashboard before the car moves |
| Return | After-hours drop-off confusion, missing fuel documentation, or return time disputes | No clear sign for the drop box, no receipt at return, or a gate that is closed when you arrive | Use the proper return lane, note the odometer and fuel level, and keep proof of the drop time |
| Billing | Deposits held too long, surprise extras, or post-return damage claims | Charges that do not match the booking screen or a bill with unexplained line items | Save screenshots, final contract, return receipt, and photos until the charge clears |
Is Hertz car rental reputable?
Hertz is a large, established rental brand with broad nationwide reach, but reputation depends heavily on the exact location and the stage of the trip. Its Yelp brand page shows an average rating of 2.1 from 71,093 reviews, which points to a high complaint volume, yet that brand-level average does not describe every branch equally.
How to read Hertz ratings and reviews
Start with the brand average, then move to the local office you will use. Hertz has 2,061 locations listed on Yelp across the US, so a branch in one airport can perform very differently from a suburban or city site. Recent reviews matter more than old ones because staffing, inventory, and local management can change.
A low overall rating often reflects repeated friction points rather than one isolated issue. For Hertz, the pattern usually clusters around wait times, billing, and vehicle availability, so a location with newer positive reviews is a better sign than a stale page full of older complaints.
Why location-level feedback matters more than brand-level averages
Airport counters can be busy, while some local branches move faster and others are short-staffed. That variation can change the whole rental. Check the specific pickup point, not just the company name, because a good branch can still sit inside a brand with weak nationwide ratings.
What are the most common Hertz complaints?
Complaints are often grouped into three broad areas: customer service delays, billing disputes, and vehicle availability problems. Those are different failures. A long phone wait is not the same as an unexpected post-return charge, and a booked compact car that becomes a different model is its own issue.

Customer service complaints: waits, phone support, and escalation
Customers frequently report long hold times, slow counter service, and difficulty reaching a person who can solve a problem on the spot. AI or bot support can handle simple requests, but it often does not resolve a reservation error, a replacement request, or a billing dispute. That is where escalation matters.
If the issue is local, ask for the branch manager or the highest on-site supervisor available before you leave. If the issue is after return, get the case number, the time stamp, and the name or identifier of the agent you reached. Location-specific service variance is real, so a bad airport desk does not prove every Hertz desk is the same.
Billing complaints: deposits, extras, and post-return charges
Billing complaints often involve deposit holds, fuel or toll add-ons, and charges that appear after the car is returned. The most common mistake is assuming the total on the booking page is the final total without checking the rental agreement. Fees can be tied to what you select, what the counter adds, or what is recorded at return.
Say your reservation shows one price, but the counter adds insurance, a young driver fee, or a different vehicle class. If you do not question it before leaving, the bill may post before you notice the change. Keep the booking confirmation and the signed contract together.
Vehicle availability complaints: swaps, upgrades, and missing cars
Vehicle availability issues usually start when the booked class is unavailable, the exact model is not ready, or the car has a mechanical problem. In those cases, staff may offer a substitution or upgrade, but that is not always automatic or free. The risk rises when demand is high and the lot is thin on inventory.
Picture a traveler who reserved an intermediate SUV for a family trip, then finds only a sedan or a different SUV trim at pickup. If the replacement does not fit luggage or seat needs, resolve it before accepting the keys. Once you pull out, your position weakens fast.
What to expect at Hertz airport locations
Airport locations can be the easiest place to find a car, but they can also be the most crowded. Hertz’s Newark Airport branch is open 24 hours every day, sits at 132 Carson Road, Newark 07114, and Hertz says it is reachable on the free AirTrain system. That convenience can come with longer lines and more rushed handoffs.

Pickup flow, shuttle access, and counter congestion
At airport sites, the pickup flow usually starts with terminal transfer or AirTrain access, then a counter check, then a garage handoff. More traffic means more chances for a wait. If you arrive during a peak flight bank, expect counter congestion and a faster pace at the desk.
Airport service can feel more efficient because the site is built for volume, but the same volume can produce the exact delays travelers complain about. A branch with a shuttle or AirTrain link is convenient, yet convenience does not remove the need to inspect the contract line by line.
24-hour hours and after-hours return
Twenty-four-hour access helps if your flight lands late or departs before dawn, but after-hours return still needs careful handling. If dropping off after hours, check where the drop box is, whether the return lane stays open, and how the location records the time if no staff member is present. That matters for billing disputes.
For Newark Airport specifically, Hertz advertises a best price guarantee there, says no cancellation or amendment fees apply up to two days before pickup, and says theft and damage cover is included with no hidden extras to pay. Those claims still need a quick read on the booking screen, because the final price can change with taxes, selected extras, or deposit terms.
Why airport locations can feel different from local branches
Airport branches usually have more inventory and longer hours, but they also handle tighter flight-driven timing, more one-way rentals, and more rushed customers. Local branches may be calmer, yet some close earlier and may have smaller fleets. The right choice depends on your schedule and how much time you have for pickup.
Hertz pricing and fee policies
Hertz says it offers a best price guarantee at Newark Airport, and it advertises no cancellation or amendment fees up to two days before pickup. It also says theft and damage cover is included with no hidden extras to pay. Those are useful promises, but you should still verify the final booking screen before you confirm.

Best price guarantee and booking fees
A best price guarantee can be helpful, but only if the competing rate and the Hertz rate are truly comparable. Check the car class, mileage terms, fuel policy, taxes, and any booking fee before you assume the lowest headline number is the lowest actual cost. Booking screens often separate base rate from final total.
No cancellation or amendment fees
The same source says no cancellation or amendment fees apply up to two days before pickup. That is a clear policy, but the cutoff matters. If your flight changes or your plans shift, make the change inside that window and keep the confirmation of the edit.
Deposit handling and extra charges to verify before you book
Deposit handling is one of the easiest places for confusion. Check whether the hold is a card authorization, how much it is, and how long it can remain on the card after return. Also confirm whether the rate includes taxes, airport surcharges, toll products, or optional cover you do not want.
- Open the booking page and save the rate, class, and pickup time.
- Read the cancellation and amendment terms before paying.
- Confirm the deposit or card hold amount.
- Check whether the rate includes airport charges, fuel rules, and cover you may decline.
- At pickup, compare the contract with the booking screen before signing.
Does Hertz Gold Plus Rewards help?
Yes, Hertz Gold Plus Rewards can reduce counter friction, especially when the desk is busy. Hertz promotes free Gold+ enrollment for express pickup and exclusive benefits, which can save time and cut some paperwork. It does not fix a shortage of cars, but it can help you move faster through pickup.
Free enrollment and express pickup
Free enrollment matters because it lowers the barrier to using the program. Express pickup can mean less time waiting in line and fewer steps at the counter, which is useful if you land late or need to leave quickly. It also helps when staff are stretched thin and the general line is slow.
When loyalty perks can reduce counter friction
Loyalty benefits can help when the location has a separate process, a designated pickup area, or clearer account details already on file. They work best when the branch has the car you reserved and enough staff to process members quickly. They do not override inventory shortages.
Limits of rewards when cars or staff are short
If the fleet is short or the desk is understaffed, rewards will not solve the core problem. A member may still face a vehicle swap, a wait, or a late return of keys. Use the program as a speed tool, not a guarantee of a perfect pickup.
A common first-timer mistake is assuming the loyalty lane means the reservation itself is protected. If the lot has no matching car, you still need to inspect the replacement before accepting it.
How bad is Hertz customer service?
Hertz customer service can be inconsistent enough to cause real trip delays, especially when you need a quick fix, a phone callback, or a billing correction. The main complaint is not one single bad interaction. It is the combination of waits, slow escalation, and location-by-location variation.
For a traveler who can spend extra time at pickup, the experience may be manageable. For someone with a tight flight or a one-hour connection, even a short delay can become a missed departure. That is why the safest approach is to verify the branch, the pickup rules, and the booking terms before arrival.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hertz car rental reliable?
Hertz can be reliable for a routine rental, but reliability drops when the rental depends on tight timing, exact vehicle class, or careful billing. The company’s strong airport presence and broad location count help, yet recent location reviews matter more than the brand average when you are trying to avoid surprises.
Is Hertz car rental good?
Hertz can be a good choice if the branch has recent positive reviews, you understand the fee terms, and you verify the car at pickup. It is less attractive when you need flexible changes or fast support. The experience depends more on the site than on the logo.
What are the most common Hertz car rental complaints?
The most common complaints are long waits, hard-to-reach support, unexpected billing items, and vehicle substitutions. Those issues do not all mean the same thing. A slow counter, a deposit hold, and a missing booked vehicle are separate problems, and each one needs a different check before you leave.
Does Hertz have hidden fees?
The same source says theft and damage cover is included with no hidden extras to pay, and it says no cancellation or amendment fees apply up to two days before pickup. The practical risk is not always a hidden fee; it is often an added item, deposit hold, or booking detail you did not review closely enough.
What should I watch out for when renting from Hertz?
Watch the booking class, the final rate, the deposit hold, and the condition of the car at pickup. Also confirm the return process, especially at airport sites with after-hours drop-off. If the contract and the booking screen do not match, fix it before you drive away.
Is Hertz better at airport locations or local branches?
Airport locations are often better for late arrivals, longer hours, and easier access from terminals. Local branches can be calmer and sometimes faster, but they may have shorter hours and smaller fleets. The better choice is the branch with the clearest recent reviews and the right pickup timing for your trip.
What is Hertz Gold Plus and does it help?
Hertz Gold Plus Rewards is the company’s free loyalty program, and Hertz promotes it for express pickup and exclusive benefits. It can help reduce counter friction and save time. It cannot fix a shortage of cars, but it can make the pickup process smoother when the location is operating normally.
Products related to this article
Sponsored / affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I may earn additional commission from eligible campaigns.


